InterNACHI


Go Back   InterNACHI Message Board > Specific Inspection Topics > Electrical

Notices

Electrical Contains discussions about electrical systems. This includes outlets, panels, wiring, et cetera.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
  #16  
Old 11/9/09, 8:26 PM
Bob Elliott's Avatar
Bob Elliott Bob Elliott is online now
InterNACHI Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Chicago
Posts: 3,058
Default Re: GFCI on 2 wire systems



I thought I was an electrician .May explain my Einstein hair.
Reply With Quote
Find an InterNACHI certified Georgia Home Inspector (and anywhere else in North America)
  #17  
Old 11/9/09, 8:30 PM
Michael Larson's Avatar
Michael Larson Michael Larson is offline
InterNACHI Member
 
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Hudson, WI including the Twin Cities of MN
Posts: 20,901
Default Re: GFCI on 2 wire systems

Quote:
Originally Posted by belliott View Post


I thought I was an electrician .May explain my Einstein hair.
I used to work with a maintence electrician that would wet two fingers and swipe at wire exposed wires to make sure they were dead.



"Never underestimate the difficulty of changing false beliefs by facts."
Henry Rosovsky-Harvard

Michael Larson
Hudson, WI

Services provided in East MN and West WI
InspectraPro
or
Minnesota Home Inspector

Reply With Quote
  #18  
Old 11/9/09, 8:40 PM
Bob Elliott's Avatar
Bob Elliott Bob Elliott is online now
InterNACHI Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Chicago
Posts: 3,058
Default Re: GFCI on 2 wire systems

Quote:
Originally Posted by mlarson View Post
I used to work with a maintence electrician that would wet two fingers and swipe at wire exposed wires to make sure they were dead.
No different from all the Gas company guys that used matches to check for leaks (OK I was guilty of that one too).

What drives me nuts is how many of the Electricians told me to work live or I was a sissy.

Other than getting scared, I ended up with many bloody knuckles from the kickback.
Reply With Quote
  #19  
Old 11/9/09, 10:10 PM
James E. Braun, CMI James E. Braun, CMI is online now
InterNACHI Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Jefferson City, MO
Posts: 3,275
Default Re: GFCI on 2 wire systems

I have had 440 three phase throw me back when I was an industrial electrician. The flash and the loud pop is unreal. I accidentally bumped some dirt and it fell in the cabinet that I was testing a circuit in. I learned to knock the dust off the panel first before I opened it.
Also once my supervisor was hauled away to the hospital because some water was lying in an electrical panel when he opened the door. I heard the loud pop and I was a good 75 yards away.
Reply With Quote
  #20  
Old 11/10/09, 12:18 AM
Chuck Evans's Avatar
Chuck Evans Chuck Evans is offline
InterNACHI Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Stagecoach, TX
Posts: 962
Default Re: GFCI on 2 wire systems

Quote:
Originally Posted by mlarson View Post
They prevent a fault current in excess of 5 mA from going through a person.

That is sufficient to prevent electrocution in most of the population.
I was referring to all of the other possibilities for electrical incidents e.g., miswired (line/load), malfunctioning, people getting shocked at switches, panels, dryer outlets, other devices, etc. People can come up with myriad ways in which to shock themselves. I just don't like to use absolute terms like "prevent" for these types of things, it can create a false sense of security for the unwitting.
Reply With Quote
  #21  
Old 11/10/09, 8:10 AM
Michael Larson's Avatar
Michael Larson Michael Larson is offline
InterNACHI Member
 
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Hudson, WI including the Twin Cities of MN
Posts: 20,901
Default Re: GFCI on 2 wire systems

I simply stated the facts.



"Never underestimate the difficulty of changing false beliefs by facts."
Henry Rosovsky-Harvard

Michael Larson
Hudson, WI

Services provided in East MN and West WI
InspectraPro
or
Minnesota Home Inspector

Reply With Quote
  #22  
Old 11/10/09, 11:20 AM
rbrady's Avatar
rbrady rbrady is offline
InterNACHI Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Eureka, CA
Posts: 619
Default Re: GFCI on 2 wire systems

Quote:
Originally Posted by cevans View Post
I wouldn't say they prevent, but rather that they reduce the potential for someone to get shocked. People can always find ways to electrocute themselves.

Many older homes' electrical systems are not grounded, however, short of fully rewiring the house, GFCI can be an effective way of providing improved protection against shocks and maintain "code" compliance with three prong outlets (use the "no equipment ground" stickers).
Since you picked up on Michaels comment but not mine, I will repeat:
They DO NOT reduce the potential for electrical shocks.

Also, the only "improved protection" they provide is to reduce the risk of death by electrocution.
You can also maintain "code compliance" by using 2-prong receptacles.

Personally I only recommend GFCI's in an ungrounded system at the same places I would recommend them with a grounded system. I do add a comment that "addition of a grounding conductor will reduce the risk of less dangerous electrical shocks".



"An expert is a person who has made all the mistakes that can be made in a very narrow field"
Niels Bohr

"Learn all you can from the mistakes of others. You won't have time to make them all yourself"
Alfred Sheinwold


Eureka, Fortuna & Arcata, CA
Reply With Quote
  #23  
Old 11/10/09, 11:42 AM
Michael Larson's Avatar
Michael Larson Michael Larson is offline
InterNACHI Member
 
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Hudson, WI including the Twin Cities of MN
Posts: 20,901
Default Re: GFCI on 2 wire systems

Quote:
Originally Posted by rbrady View Post
Personally I only recommend GFCI's in an ungrounded system at the same places I would recommend them with a grounded system. I do add a comment that "addition of a grounding conductor will reduce the risk of less dangerous electrical shocks".
Agreed



"Never underestimate the difficulty of changing false beliefs by facts."
Henry Rosovsky-Harvard

Michael Larson
Hudson, WI

Services provided in East MN and West WI
InspectraPro
or
Minnesota Home Inspector

Reply With Quote
  #24  
Old 11/10/09, 1:04 PM
George P. Wells's Avatar
George P. Wells George P. Wells is offline
InterNACHI Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Michigan
Posts: 399
Send a message via Skype™ to gwells
Default Re: GFCI on 2 wire systems

Quote:
Originally Posted by rbrady View Post
From what I have heard, at least 220 will knock you off, unlike 110 which just makes your muscles hold tighter.
That is false.



BestInspectors.Net

http://www.bestinspectors.net
Reply With Quote
  #25  
Old 11/10/09, 1:49 PM
George P. Wells's Avatar
George P. Wells George P. Wells is offline
InterNACHI Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Michigan
Posts: 399
Send a message via Skype™ to gwells
Default Re: GFCI on 2 wire systems

Quote:
Originally Posted by thowell View Post
Looking for some help on clarification. My understanding is a GFCI will prevent elec shock in a 2 wire system. I have seen them in bathrooms and kitchens. The part that trips me up is, a 2 wire system is still not grounded. That should be a safety concern, but not unsafe with a GFCI installed. (correct?)
Second part of question, in a home with 2 wire outlets why couldn't a person put GFCIs in all the locations? Like the living room for example. I was ask this question the other day. The occupants would be protected, correct?
Thanks folks.
Tim, without getting into a long detailed explanation (which most would probably find boring anyway), let me dispel one common misunderstanding. Two-wire systems are grounded. It is because they are grounded that GFCIs work on them.

Damage caused by electrical shock is a function of time and current. Humans are particularly vulnerable to electric current. The challenge to manufacturers of GFCI devices is to limit current to a where it cannot seriously injure a person but do not deenergize circuits that should not be deenergized. Some loads (specifically, reactive loads) are more difficult than others.

GFCI receptacles have come a long way since the early GFCI devices still, they should not be used on circuits that have heavy motor loads because they could trip when we don't want them to trip. It would be a good idea, for example, not to put a refrigerator on a GFCI receptacle.

It is worth noting that false tripping problems only arise with reactive loads (motors, capacitors, etc). Resistive loads (heating elements, etc) do not cause false tripping (unless, of course, the appliance has malfunctioned).



BestInspectors.Net

http://www.bestinspectors.net
Reply With Quote
  #26  
Old 11/10/09, 7:23 PM
Larry F. Rollins Larry F. Rollins is offline
InterNACHI Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Nashville, Tn
Posts: 118
Default Re: GFCI on 2 wire systems

Quote:
Originally Posted by rbrady View Post
Have you ever tripped a GFCI with your body (across two fingers doesn't count)? I don't recommend trying it, but would be interested in hearing if anyone has.

From what I have heard, at least 220 will knock you off, unlike 110 which just makes your muscles hold tighter.

While in electricians school(many moons ago) one instructor took an entire class to prove that a AAA battery could potentially kill a person. The technique involved two pieces of wire, two needles and a soldering iron. {you figure it out} He showed where if a needle was stuck in each arm(into a vein) and the battery applied, enough current would flow to stop the heart. As I remember, and it has been many years, .1 milliamp will stop the heart.
Both 220 and 110 will "tend" to throw you off since they are AC voltages. It is DC voltages that will lock you on. Granted 220vac will do a much better job of throwing you off than 110vac will. The rule of thumb is Low voltage AC and Hi voltage DC are the most dangerous.
My largest shock was aboard a submarine where I took a "shot" from the back of my upper arm to my sweaty hand through a pinhole leak in a pair of heavy rubber gloves. It was 440 vac, 400 cycle. Came to about 10 feet away and couldn't use my arm for awhile. The burns hurt like hell. The only long term affect was a very strong desire to never do it again!
Reply With Quote
  #27  
Old 11/10/09, 8:26 PM
rbrady's Avatar
rbrady rbrady is offline
InterNACHI Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Eureka, CA
Posts: 619
Default Re: GFCI on 2 wire systems

Quote:
Originally Posted by gwells View Post
let me dispel one common misunderstanding. Two-wire systems are grounded.
I think most everyone understands that the neutral wire is the 'grounded conductor', and as such is grounded, even in a 2-wire system. It's kind of a given, that when we discuss un-grounded systems, we are refering to the lack of a 'grounding conductor'.

One thing that I think most people don't realize is that grounding the system acutally increases the risk of shock. If both conductors were isolated from ground, you would have to make contact with both sides (positive & negative) to get a shock - earth ground would not be the negative side. Grounding is used to stabilize the voltage.



"An expert is a person who has made all the mistakes that can be made in a very narrow field"
Niels Bohr

"Learn all you can from the mistakes of others. You won't have time to make them all yourself"
Alfred Sheinwold


Eureka, Fortuna & Arcata, CA
Reply With Quote
  #28  
Old 11/10/09, 8:55 PM
Jim Port Jim Port is offline
Unmoderated Guest
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Maryland
Posts: 359
Please Note: Jim Port is a non-member guest and is in no way affiliated with InterNACHI or its members.
Default Re: GFCI on 2 wire systems

Quote:
Originally Posted by gwells View Post
GFCI receptacles have come a long way since the early GFCI devices still, they should not be used on circuits that have heavy motor loads because they could trip when we don't want them to trip. It would be a good idea, for example, not to put a refrigerator on a GFCI receptacle.

It is worth noting that false tripping problems only arise with reactive loads (motors, capacitors, etc). Resistive loads (heating elements, etc) do not cause false tripping (unless, of course, the appliance has malfunctioned).
If motor loads are causing a GFI to trip the appliance is leaking current in excess of the allowable UL amount. For example a sump pump motor under the UL standard is only allowed to leak a small fraction of the 4-6mA that a Class A GFI would trip at. I cannot find the exact leakage allowed.

As a side note refrigerators in a commercial kitchen are REQUIRED to be GFI protected.

I would ask which is better, a refrigerator with a tripped GFIand spoiled food or a faulty refrigerator with a fault and a dead person?
Reply With Quote
Find an InterNACHI certified Georgia Home Inspector (and anywhere else in North America)
  #29  
Old 11/10/09, 8:57 PM
John Shishilla's Avatar
John Shishilla John Shishilla is offline
InterNACHI Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Palm Bay, FL
Posts: 580
Default Re: GFCI on 2 wire systems


Those of you that try to predict when an electric current will, hurt, make you hold on, make you let go kill or seriously injure you are doing a disservice to those that are looking for answers.

It takes VERY little current to kill a person under the right circumstances A/C or D/C. If you must have a specific answer it is less than a milli amp. It can not be predicted with any degree of accuracy, to try is reckless.

I will step off the soap box now.




John Shishilla

Residential Contractor
Accredited Claims Adjuster (ACA)

Serving all of Brevard including: Melbourne, Palm Bay, Cocoa, Rockledge, Viera, Satellite Beach, Indian Harbor Beach, Cape Canaveral, Indialantic and surrounding areas.

Honor Construction
www.honorconstruction.com
www.honorinspections.com
"Brevard's Premiere Inspection Company"

321-327-2950

Reply With Quote
  #30  
Old 11/10/09, 9:02 PM
Michael Larson's Avatar
Michael Larson Michael Larson is offline
InterNACHI Member
 
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Hudson, WI including the Twin Cities of MN
Posts: 20,901
Default Re: GFCI on 2 wire systems

Quote:
Originally Posted by jshishilla View Post

Those of you that try to predict when an electric current will, hurt, make you hold on, make you let go kill or seriously injure you are doing a disservice to those that are looking for answers.

It takes VERY little current to kill a person under the right circumstances A/C or D/C. If you must have a specific answer it is less than a milli amp. It can not be predicted with any degree of accuracy, to try is reckless.

I will step off the soap box now.
As I said earlier 5 mA is non lethal in a normal person.

Hospital requirements are much lower for patient care areas. The limits are on the order of 100 microAmps allowable leakage current and 10 microAmps in certain areas without gong into more detail than is needed here.



"Never underestimate the difficulty of changing false beliefs by facts."
Henry Rosovsky-Harvard

Michael Larson
Hudson, WI

Services provided in East MN and West WI
InspectraPro
or
Minnesota Home Inspector

Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
"UFER" Ground? see last paragraph. jtedesco1 Electrical 6 9/15/08 7:57 AM
What's this video worth? jtedesco1 Education 5 4/18/08 9:24 AM
Nice Report on AL Wire Terminations - Enjoy pabernathy Electrical 0 7/2/07 12:35 PM
PIC of State Rep and sponsor of new NACHI H.I. Bill in NH. gromicko Misc. Discussion 53 8/30/06 5:58 PM
Emergency Lighting (commercial) mcyr Electrical 24 6/10/06 10:06 AM


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 11:45 AM.


Popular Sections

:

All Sections

Popular

Membership

Inspection Standards

Education

Chapters & Members

Articles & Links

Other Organizations

 

 

 

NACHI.ORG Statistics

 

 

no new posts