Easy poll and hopefully Nick and InterNACHI staff can implement.
Should threads more than a year old be locked for additional comment? We have Zombie threads from 5-10-15 years ago popping up with new questions and comments. If these are locked as “read only”, people can start new threads for information. Just an idea.
Make it so that when someone trys to post a new post it creates a new thread with a reference to the old thread included as a link… maybe… thinking out loud here. :lol:
Voting not as I inspected. I am curious why someone would want to allow comments on an old thread that has had no activity for 5-10 years. 50% of the time is is a spam post from someone pushing some link. Isn’t a new thread better? Anybody want to discuss the reasons for their NO vote?
But when you go and delete them because it serves your own personal agenda it keeps all from learning from them (good or bad, it’s censoring) and thus harms all members.
That’s not what this poll is about. It’s about Commenting on Old threads. It doesn’t say anything about reading old threads, or removing old threads. It’s about newbie inspector’s, or ones that don’t visit very often, reviving a seven or eight year old thread and then answering a question that has already been answered many years ago, or posting a new comment that is not even relevant anymore.
And even better when there is updated information in them.
There was one thread, I forget the topic, but Jeff Pope has posted an answer in a thread then a year later, updated his answer to clarify the first answer.
We’d be better served deleting some of the new crap threads that get posted here asking the same basic questions for the umpteenth time this year alone!!! It’s very telling when a newbie needs to search back 5-10-15 years to get to some quality information versus this crap being posted today!
Reason I voted no is because sometimes known information at the time was wrong and it can be updated.perhaps have old threads over say 2 years be in a special archive group.