Collar Ties vs. Rafter Ties
by Nick Gromicko and Ben Gromicko
Collar ties and rafter ties are both horizontal roof-framing members, each with different purposes and requirements. Home inspectors
should be familiar with these structural members and the differences between them, as they are not the same.
In physics, tension
is the pulling
force exerted by a solid object on another object. Tension members are solid
objects (or structural members) that are subjected to axial tensile forces, or tension. Collar ties and rafter ties are examples of tension members.
A tension tie is a structural
member that is subject to net tension.
"Collar tie" is a colloquial phrase that is used among contractors, builders and inspectors, but not usually used in construction or engineering documentation. The correct phrase is actually “collar beam.” In this article, we’ll use "collar tie."
A collar tie is a tension tie in the upper third of opposing gable rafters that is intended to resist
rafter separation from the ridge beam during periods of unbalanced loads, such as that caused by wind uplift, or unbalanced roof loads from snow. The 2012 International
Residential Code does not require collar ties (or collar beams). However, in
those situations when they are specified, collar ties are usually installed in
the upper third of the roof between opposing rafters. In high-wind areas, uplift can tear a roof off of a house if it's not properly attached.
Collar ties must be at least 1 x 4
inches (nominal), spaced not more than 4 feet on
Other facts about collar ties:
- They may or may not be required, depending on jurisdiction. InterNACHI inspectors should not call out a lack of collar ties as a defect unless they know that collar ties were required in the jurisdiction where the home is located at the time the home was built.
- Collar ties are probably not needed if metal connectors were used to fasten the rafters to the ridge.
- Where they are required, they should be installed on every other rafter where rafters are on 24-inch centers.
- Collar ties, contrary to popular belief, do not prevent walls from spreading.
A rafter tie is a tension
tie in the lower third of opposing gable rafters that is intended to resist the
outward thrust of the rafter under a load. The roof framing mock-up below shows a standard rafter tie.
Rafter ties are installed between opposing rafters, and they should be installed as close as possible to the top plate.
When they run parallel to the
rafters, ceiling joists can function as rafter ties. Rafter ties resist the outward
thrust that rafters exert on the exterior walls. They help keep walls from spreading due to the weight of the roof. When the walls spread, the ridge board might sag. A sagging ridge is one indication that the roof structure may lack adequate rafter ties. A rafter tie forms the bottom chord of a simple triangular roof truss.
When ceiling joists
run perpendicular to the rafters, inspectors may find rafter ties installed
above ceiling joists as framing members every 4 feet running above the
ceiling joists connecting opposing rafters.
Rafter ties should be at least 2 x 4 inches (nominal).
Other facts about rafter ties:
- Rafter ties are always required unless the roof has a structural (self-supporting) ridge, or is built using engineered trusses. A lack of rafter ties is a serious structural issue in a conventionally framed roof.
- In most homes, the ceiling joists also serve as the rafter ties.
- Where rafters are oriented perpendicular to the ceiling joists, rafter ties should be installed just above the ceiling joists. The ties usually rest on the joists.
- When rafters are installed on 24-inch centers, rafter ties are typically installed at every other rafter.
- It’s not unusual to see rafter ties of either 2 x 4-inch or 2 x 6-inch.
Rafter and collar ties are subject to enormous tension forces. These forces make securing the ties to the rafter boards a critical issue. The force in each tie increases with the
inverse of the slope. So, the greater the roof slope, the weaker the outward thrust.
The load on a structure can be calculated from combining the dead load
or weight of the structure itself, the live load that varies for
different structures, the snow load, and the wind load.
In a simple gable roof, the rafter boards carry the
live and dead loads that push both downward and outward against the top of the load-bearing
walls. This horizontal outward thrust can be considerable. To resist this
horizontal outward thrust, the International Residential Code calls for each
pair of rafters to be securely connected to each other by a continuous ceiling
joist, and for a structural ridge beam to be installed for roofs with a slope of less
than 3:12 (see illustration below).
Where ceiling joists are not connected to the
rafters at the top wall plate, joists connected higher in the attic shall be
installed as rafter ties, or a
continuous tie should be provided. Where ceiling joists are not parallel to rafters, rafter ties
shall be installed. Where ceiling joists or rafter ties are not provided, the
ridge formed by these rafters must be supported by a wall or girder.
The ends of ceiling joists should be lapped a minimum
of 3 inches, or butted over bearing partitions or beams and toenailed to
the bearing member. Where ceiling joists are used to provide resistance to
rafter thrust, lapped joists shall be nailed together in accordance with Table
R802.5.1(9) in the IRC. For example, if a house has a 4:12 slope, the rafters are on 16-inch centers, the snow load is 30 psf, and the roof span is 28 feet, you need eight 16d common nails (or 40d box nails) at each rafter-heel joint connection. That's a lot of nails a home inspector can look for.
Cathedral ceilings are popular in many homes, but they have special issues with the downward load on the rafters that push outward on the exterior walls. Open collar ties and ridge beams address many of these issues. The higher the tie is located, the less leverage is available to counteract the outward-thrust forces. Many cathedral ceilings often display indications of movement, such as cracked drywall. The most effective way to reduce outward thrust is to use a structural ridge beam.
Bottom Chord of a Truss
In a conventional roof truss, the bottom chord acts as a tension tie between the exterior walls. Alterations to installed trusses are not permitted. Cutting any truss, particularly at the bottom chord, destroys the structural integrity of the truss. If the inspector finds that the chord of a truss has been cut, he/she should recommend that a structural engineer be consulted.
The bottom chord of a truss should not be attached to an interior wall partition. Attaching the bottom chord of a truss to an inside wall can cause the web members designed for tension to become compression members. When the bottom chord is nailed to a top plate of an interior wall, a home inspector might observe cracking interior finishes at the corner of the finished wall and ceiling.
Older building codes permitted rafter ties to be installed very high above the top wall plate, as much as two-thirds the distance between the top plate and the ridge. The 2012 IRC now limits this to one-third the distance between the plate and the ridge. For example, if an unfinished garage has a roof with a 4:12 slope and the roof span is 24 feet, the rafter ties should be located no more than 16 inches up from the plate, according to modern building standards.
The roof framing mock-up below shows a standard collar tie. As the load is applied downward, tension in the collar tie is increased.
The illustration below shows a king post truss on posts. As the load is applied downward, compression is increased at the posts.
A bending moment occurs when a force changes from a straight form into a curved or angular one. The illustration below shows a collar tie with rafters on top of conventionally framed walls. As the load is applied downward, the rafters go into a bending moment below the collar tie. This bending moment exerts outward thrust on the walls, making them out of plumb.
In summary, collar ties and rafter ties perform different functions, but both are essential roof-framing members, and it's useful for inspectors to be aware of their differences in order to properly call out defects.