November 5, 2025
After more than two years of litigation in which InterNACHI filed amicus curiae briefs in support of an InterNACHI home inspector's position, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court recently issued a 7-0 decision, siding with InterNACHI and the InterNACHI member and concluding that Pennsylvania law required any lawsuit to be brought within one year of the inspection date.
By way of background, more than two years after the home inspection was completed, the homeowner sued the home inspector, claiming the home inspector had not included in his report alleged issues with plumbing and insulation in a crawl space in the home. With InterNACHI's support, the inspector was successful in convincing an intermediate Pennsylvania appellate court that the homeowner's lawsuit filed over two years after the inspection was untimely.
The homeowner then appealed to the Supreme Court claiming the time clock to file the lawsuit began to run when they discovered the alleged issue with the home, not when the inspection was performed. However, Pennsylvania, like many states has a law that requires the lawsuit to be commenced within one year of the inspection date, regardless of when the homeowner claims they discovered the alleged issue. These laws are known as statutes of repose, and protect inspectors from stale claims.
InterNACHI has been instrumental in lobbying for such laws that help protect home inspectors from stale lawsuits, thereby limiting their risk and keeping down their operating expenses.
The Pennsylvania Supreme Court heard the case and on October 23, 2025 issued a 7-0 decision, siding with InterNACHI and the InterNACHI member.
InterNACHI was pleased to support its member in this successful outcome.
We congratulate the inspector and express our thanks to our attorneys Timothy Maffet of Baker, Donelson, Bearman, Caldwell & Berkowitz, P.C. and Frank Lopez of Glade, Voogt, Lopez, & Smith, P.C.
68-0!
Join our discussion regarding this victory.
Court Documents:
2023 InterNACHI Amicus Brief.pdf
2024 InterNACHI Amicus Brief.pdf.
2025 Unanimous Opinion of the Supreme Court .pdf
###