Inspecting the Concrete, Cracking, and Water Connection (IRC® R406)

by Nick Gromicko and Ben Gromicko

There are only two types of concrete: the kind that's already cracked and the kind that will crack. And the most concerning crack is one that water uses as a pathway to infiltrate the foundation.

In this article, we'll explore how water serves as both the critical component in the original concrete mixture and the persistent destroyer that continuously seeks to pressure its way through openings. To keep homes with concrete foundations safe, functioning, and healthy, we must understand why concrete cracks and how water may not only cause these fissures but also provide telling clues about inadequate water management around a property.

This inspection training article will change how home inspectors, code inspectors, and contractors evaluate concrete by revealing the connections between:

What goes into the mix
What the building code requires
Why moisture movement matters more than you think
How to spot the warning signs that others miss

When a homeowner asks, "Is this crack normal?" they're really asking about the structural integrity, water resistance, and longevity of one of their home's most fundamental elements. The answer depends on understanding what's happening beneath the surface.

Let's start with the building code and the strength of concrete in pounds per square inch (psi).

Code for Concrete

Chapter 4 of International Residential Code (IRC) establishes minimum strength requirements for different concrete applications in residential construction, based on the specific stresses each element must withstand. Inside the code book, there's recipe for concrete. It explains how strong different types of concrete need to be depending on where they're used in a house. Code makes sure contractors use concrete that's strong enough for each specific job. Think of it like this: you need strong boots for hiking and slippers for walking in your living room. Similarly, concrete that supports an entire house needs to be stronger than concrete used for less critical purposes. These requirements help ensure your home is built safely and will stand the test of time. Below is the IRC Table R402.2.

The minimum concrete compressive strengths range from 2,500 to 3,500 psi. Table R402.2 specifies the required compressive strength of concrete based on the weathering potential and a building element's exposure.

Interior applications (footings, foundations, and basement slabs): minimum 2,500 psi
Exterior slabs exposed to weather (patios, walkways, driveways): minimum 3,000 psi

These requirements aren't arbitrary—they're carefully calculated to ensure concrete can resist the specific environmental and structural forces it will encounter throughout a home's lifespan.

But here's what most contractors don't tell homeowners: meeting code requirements on paper doesn't guarantee performance in practice. The real story of concrete quality begins with water—how much was used, where it went, and what pathways it created for future problems.

So, why would concrete fail if looks properly mixed and installed during construction? It may be related to the water.

The Strength-Moisture Connection

Understanding how concrete's initial composition affects its long-term performance creates a clear picture of why the building code mandates specific strength requirements. So, let's look into the ratio of water to cement.

Water-Strength Relationship

The ratio of water to cement in mixing concrete can controlled to ensure that the concrete reaches the specified strength. Adding more water when mixing concrete makes it easier to work with, but it creates two big problems: the concrete gets weaker (can't hold as much weight) and it shrinks more as it dries (causing cracks).

On site, contractors should add the minimum amount of water needed to make the concrete workable. The sketch shows that adding just 2 gallons of water per cubic yard of concrete makes it 10% weaker and causes 20% more shrinkage. This is why properly mixed concrete is so important for things like driveways and house foundations.

Higher water content during mixing directly reduces compressive strength (psi rating)
Every gallon of water added per cubic yard beyond the designed mixture reduces strength by approximately 200 psi
Concrete mixed at the minimum 2,500 psi for interior applications could drop below code requirements if excessive water is added on-site

Porosity and Moisture Migration

When concrete is mixed with excessive water, it creates significant problems extending beyond mere strength reduction. As this water-laden mixture dries and hardens, it develops a vast network of interconnected capillary pathways as water evaporates, creating channels as small as a micrometer in diameter.

Concrete mixed with excessive water develops interconnected capillary networks as water evaporates
These capillary pathways remain permanent features of the cured concrete
Over time, groundwater can migrate through these pathways via capillary action
This migration exerts hydrostatic pressure against the concrete structure

These microscopic networks act like tiny straws that draw moisture, mineral salt, and other substances deep into the concrete through capillary action. The more water added during mixing, the more extensive these networks become, leading to increased shrinkage cracks and compromised durability, waterproofing capabilities, and freeze-thaw resistance of the concrete structure.

This capillary phenomenon isn't limited to poured concrete - it affects virtually all masonry materials used in building construction, including:

natural stone (particularly limestone and sandstone),
manufactured stone products, and
concrete masonry units (CMUs).

These materials all contain similar capillary networks, though their characteristics vary based on composition and manufacturing. This inherent porosity underscores why comprehensive water management systems are absolutely critical in construction.

Proper foundation drainage, dampproofing, and vapor barriers can work collectively to interrupt these capillary pathways. Without these protective measures, groundwater and soil moisture will inevitably migrate through the material's capillary network, potentially causing efflorescence, interior dampness, mold growth, and even structural deterioration over time.

For home inspectors, identifying deficiencies in these water management systems becomes as important as examining the condition of the materials themselves.

Freeze-Thaw Damage

Exterior concrete (requiring 3,000 psi) must withstand freezing temperatures. Water that migrates into concrete through capillary action expands approximately 9% when frozen. This expansion creates internal pressures exceeding 4,000 psi. Concrete with a 3,000 psi rating, but compromised by excessive mixing water, may fall below the strength needed to resist these freeze-thaw pressures. The result is cracking, spalling, and progressive deterioration.

Connecting Code to Conditions

When evaluating concrete elements during home inspections, understanding these interconnections allows home inspectors to provide more insightful assessments:

Foundation walls showing efflorescence: Indicates ongoing capillary moisture migration that may be compromising the concrete's structural integrity below the required 2,500 psi effective strength
Exterior slabs with cracking, scaling, or spalling: Suggests concrete that likely didn't maintain the IRC-mandated 3,000 psi necessary to withstand freeze-thaw cycles, possibly due to excessive water addition during placement
Basement slabs showing signs of moisture migration: May indicate concrete that technically met code requirements for compressive strength (2,500 psi) but contains excessive capillary networks due to high water-cement ratios during mixing

By connecting visible conditions to concrete basics and code requirements, home inspectors can provide clients with a more comprehensive understanding of potential structural and moisture-related concerns, helping them make informed decisions about remediation priorities and long-term maintenance strategies.

Remember, the International Residential Code (IRC) establishes minimum requirements assuming proper concrete mixing and placement procedures. When water content is improperly managed during installation, concrete may meet specifications on paper while failing to deliver the real-world performance that code requirements are designed to ensure.

The Water-Concrete Connection

Water: Concrete's Creator and Destroyer

Water plays a paradoxical role in concrete's lifecycle—it's both essential for the initial chemical reaction that creates concrete and the primary agent of deterioration over time. Excessive water creates permanent capillary networks that remain after curing. Excess water reduces strength. Capillary action draws moisture pathways. Internal pressures can damage concrete.

When inspecting concrete systems, visible conditions provide critical clues about invisible structural integrity, including efflorescence, cracking and spalling, and moisture intrusion.

Concrete can provide information about the water management around a property. By connect visible conditions to concrete basics and code requirements, home inspectors can provide clients with valuable information about structural and moisture-related concerns. Every home, including the parts made out of concrete, should be inspected by an InterNACHI® Certified Professional Inspector CPI® to help ensure our homes are safe, functioning, and healthy.

More Information

To learn more about homes, inspections, and building standards, visit www.nachi.org/education.

To become a certified home inspector, visit www.nachi.org/certifications.

Join the International Association of Professional Contractors.

Inspecting the Concrete, Cracking, and Water Connection (IRC® R406)

Code for Concrete

The Strength-Moisture Connection

Water-Strength Relationship

Porosity and Moisture Migration

Freeze-Thaw Damage

Connecting Code to Conditions

The Water-Concrete Connection

Further Reading

More Information

Certification & Licensing

Education

Resources

Get Started

Grow Your Business

More…